An important aspect of community management is community moderation. Checking if everyone is engaging with one another appropriately ensures the community feels welcoming and people feel free to share their thoughts and ideas. Knowing the community manager has the community and its individual members’ backs gives users the trust to remain active within the platform. 

To ensure people interact with each other in a respectful and constructive manner when they first enter your community, be sure to set up some basic community guidelines and share them in your welcome email with new members so they have an idea of what your community is about and how they should engage with one another. 

Because you want people to feel positive about your community when they first join, make sure you focus your guidelines on what people should do, rather than what they shouldn’t. This is why we prefer to use the term ‘guidelines’, because ‘guidelines’ feel less restrictive than other terms such as ‘house rules’ for example. 

As guidelines are always a work in progress that evolves with the community over time, don’t be afraid to get them ‘wrong’. You can always adjust them at a later date, just don’t adjust them too often to avoid confusion. It’s good to set up your community guidelines with members of the community, so the Beta period is an excellent time to discuss what guidelines are appropriate for your community. 

Examples of community guidelines

Good community guidelines are short and simple. They let a community know how users are expected to interact with one another. Be sure to try and capture the personality and beliefs of the community and make sure you aren’t too restricting, because people may become afraid to post. Your main goal with your guidelines is to ensure people interact with each other in a civil manner without making anyone feel unwelcome and to set some boundaries for content that isn’t allowed under any circumstances (for example: personal attacks, ‘doxing’- i.e. sharing private details of a community member-, racism and sexism). 

Het is an example of some basic community guidelines to start you off:

[Your community goal]

Do
Respect each other. This may be an online venue, but we’re all equals no matter where we share our thoughts and opinions.
Keep your comments focused and on topic, according to each post. This helps facilitate the best, most productive conversations. If you have bigger ideas, send us an email or give us a ring. We’re happy to hear from you.
Protect your privacy. Comments on this community are visible to anyone in this community. You shouldn’t post anything here that you wouldn’t say in public. Protect your privacy and don’t give out personal information such as email addresses, telephone numbers or street addresses.

Don’t
Be hateful. Disagreements can lead to great progress. However, insulting individuals will not be tolerated. Comments that use racism, sexism or are discriminatory or defamatory are not allowed and will be removed immediately.

There’s a great discussion on Quora where users have collected examples of existing community guidelines for inspiration, be sure to check them out. 

Moderation

Moderation

Now that you have guidelines you have a solid foundation to start moderating your community. Keep in mind that most people tend not to read the fine print, so make sure the first step towards moderation is reminding people of the guidelines. 

There’s more to moderation than looking out for offensive or problematic content and discussions getting out of hand. You may also want to refer users back to existing topics or groups when they create duplicates, close inactive groups or simply help users edit or close their accounts if they experience some kind of problem.

Open Social offers several options to help community managers moderate their communities:

 

  • Delete content
  • Edit content
  • Submitting content under another user’s name 
  • Changing the authorship of content 
  • Closing comment threads 
  • Closing or blocking user accounts 
  • Content flagging (coming soon!)

However, with great power comes great responsibility, so we recommend you check our steps to moderation to understand how to best use the above toolset: 

Steps to moderation

  1. Unless the content is extremely offensive or even illegal, don’t delete content straight away as people experience this as censorship.
  2. First, keep an eye on the discussion to see if the community corrects itself and if (other) users step in to correct the undesirable behavior.
  3. If the problem remains try and help steer the conversation in the right direction by referring to the guidelines and reminding the person or people involved that this type of behavior isn’t welcome. 
  4. If the person or people continue their behavior, contact them via a personal email or message and give them a warning to let them know they will be removed from the community if they continue in this way.
  5. If the person or people involved still continue, block their account and delete the offending content. Be sure to make a statement to the general community explaining the situation and your decision. 

What are your experiences with community guidelines and moderation? Are there any rules you feel we didn’t include that are absolutely essential to a healthy community? Let us know in the comments! 

Further reading

250+ Communities are powered by Open Social

Don't miss our posts

Nov 13, 2017 - Security - Drupal Community - Open Source

Embracing Open Source Security with Drupal

Open source security for online community platforms is important to us at Open Social. Here’s an overview of open source security, and why it’s important that we’re covered by the Drupal security team.

posted by Natasha
Nov 02, 2017 - User Experience - Community Building

Why Use Mentions (@) to Boost Community Engagement?

Community engagement breathes life into a community and results from vocal, passionate members. Open Social’s mention feature makes it easier for members to engage and connect with each other.

posted by Evelien
Oct 30, 2017 - User Experience - Community Building

Improve Your Community’s Accessibility

Web accessibility ensures that everyone has equal access to content on the web. Here are few actions that community managers can take to make their community accessible to everyone.

posted by Bas